At Peace Parents Podcast

Should my PDA child stay in the public school system, move to a private school, or homeschool? There is no single answer, and this episode is not going to give you one. What it is going to give you is a framework for making the decision that fits your child, your constraints, and this specific season of your family.
In this episode I walk through all five characteristics of PDA as they play out in a school or home setting, then move into the three schooling scenarios I see families navigate most: staying in the public school system and advocating for accommodations, finding a private school that is structurally more aligned with a PDA nervous system, and pulling your child out entirely to unschool, deschool, or homeschool. For each one I share what to watch for, what has worked for the families I have coached, and how to use the cost-benefit framework to make and hold a decision even when it is hard.
Key Takeaways

Why Traditional School Is Structurally Activating and What That Looks Like | 00:01:42 Traditional schools are designed to standardize: every child doing the same thing at the same time in the same way. For a PDA nervous system, that structure produces continuous perceived losses of autonomy, and the behavioral expression of that activation, whether it is equalizing behavior in the classroom or a collapse at home after a day of masking, is what most families are already living with when they find me. What I want parents to understand is that the equalizing and collapse is not defiance. It is not willfulness. It is a nervous system doing exactly what it is wired to do when it perceives repeated losses of autonomy and equality.


Advocating in the Public School System: Be Strategic, Not Educational | 00:33:27 When advocating for a PDA child in a US public school, leading with the PDA label rarely works. I give families permission to describe their child as high functioning autistic with severe anxiety or a nervous system disability, using language that the people in the room already have a framework for. From there, the most effective tool is the PLATO nonviolent communication framework: making one specific, granular request that includes a person, location, action, time, and object, so the school can only say yes, no, or propose an alternative. Each answer is data, not a defeat.


What to Look for in a Private School and Which Models Have Worked | 00:42:38 The question I ask every private school when evaluating fit is: does every child have to do the same thing at the same time in the same way? The models that have worked most consistently for families I have coached are Montessori and Reggio Emilia for their mixed-age classrooms, built-in choice, and absence of homework and grades; Sudbury Democratic Schools for their consent-based, student-governed structure; and trauma-informed schools that do not default to exposure as the primary intervention for anxiety. Even within the public system, some charter schools and schools of choice have been workable when a parent has been able to build a genuine relationship with specific staff.


Unschooling Is Not Independent Play: The Four Regulating States | 00:53:59 The most common mistake families make when they begin unschooling is assuming the child will go off and self-direct once the external structure is removed. What I observe is that PDA children need nervous system scaffolding to engage with anything. The four regulating states that help during this period are screens, another safe nervous system offering undivided attention, special interest or flow, and dopamine-intense or sensory-seeking activity. If a child is in burnout, they may only be able to access two of these. Starting there, without expectation or timeline, is the beginning of recovery, not a sign that unschooling is failing.


Strewing, Declarative Language, and Letting Go of the Timeline | 00:54:42 The three tools I return to most consistently with unschooling families are strewing, declarative language, and releasing the timeline. Strewing means leaving things out in the environment that the child can engage with or not, without expectation. Declarative language replaces direct questions and imperatives with observational statements so the child retains autonomy over whether and how to engage. And letting go of the timeline is the hardest but most necessary piece, because a parent's urgency about reading, socialization, or catching up is itself perceived by the PDA nervous system as an agenda, which activates the very resistance we are trying to reduce.

Relevant Resources

Paradigm Shift Program — My signature program where the five-characteristic framework, cost-benefit decision making, the PLATO advocacy tool, and the full unschooling and accommodation approach described in this episode are taught across twelve weeks of live coaching.
Mentioned in this episode:
Free Live Workshop
I'm offering a free live workshop this month: "Supporting your PDA child or teen through burnout without breaking yourself in the process."
Free Live Workshop Registration

Why are so many children and teens struggling with anxiety, depression, and school refusal right now? And why are so many of them PDA? I have been carrying these questions for years, and Dr. Peter Gray's new book Restoring Childhood gave me a framework I did not have before.
Dr. Peter Gray is a research professor of psychology and neuroscience at Boston College, founder of the nonprofit Let Grow, and author of Free to Learn and, just published this month, Restoring Childhood, How to Set Kids Free in the Age of Anxiety. In this episode we talk about what play actually is and why it matters for development, why the evidence does not support that screens and social media are the primary driver of the youth mental health crisis, and what has actually been happening to children's autonomy and mental health since the 1950s. We also talk about his own son, who he believes would have been identified as PDA, and how that son changed the entire trajectory of Dr. Gray's research and writing.
Key Takeaways

What Play Actually Is and Why Screens Can Count | 00:11:41 Dr. Gray defines play through four characteristics: it is self-chosen and self-directed, intrinsically motivated, structured by the players themselves, and always creative within that structure. By this definition, when my younger son spent ten to twelve hours a day in Minecraft during burnout, starting alone and gradually inviting his dad, then friends, and setting all the rules collectively, that was play. Dr. Gray affirms this directly: children are amazing at knowing what they need, and digital spaces can function as genuine play spaces when children have control over what they do there and with whom.

The Youth Mental Health Crisis Started Decades Before Social Media | 00:34:23 The data shows a steady, nearly linear increase in anxiety, depression, and suicide among school-aged children in the United States from 1950 to 1990, long before smartphones existed. Every major meta-analysis of the hundreds of studies testing the social media hypothesis shows either no meaningful correlation, or a small one that washes out across the full literature. What the cross-national data does show is that countries where schooling became more pressurized and narrow around the same time saw similar increases in youth mental health struggles, while countries that did not make those changes did not. This is not a social media story. It is an autonomy story.

Why School Is the Most Consistent Source of Stress for Children | 01:06:26 Every study Dr. Gray has found where a demographically balanced sample of school-aged children are asked to name their primary source of stress places school at the top. Pediatric mental health admissions are approximately twice as high during the school year as when school is not in session. The No Child Left Behind Act and the subsequent adoption of Common Core around 2010 narrowed the curriculum, removed teacher discretion, and replaced intrinsic engagement with test preparation, making school significantly more stressful at exactly the moment when youth mental health data began declining again.

Why PDA Children May Have Always Existed but Only Now Reach Burnout | 01:18:30 Dr. Gray's model of a narrowing channel helps me understand something I am asked constantly: why did PDA traits that existed in prior generations not produce the burnout, school refusal, and basic needs collapse I see across thousands of families today? If a child with a strong survival drive for autonomy is living in a society with more space for that autonomy, through outdoor play, age-mixed peer groups, and less compliance-based schooling, the nervous system is not accumulating the same load. As the channel for all children has narrowed across every decade since the 1950s, the children with the most sensitive neuroception for autonomy loss are the first and hardest hit.

Autonomy-Supportive Parenting and What It Asks of Us | 01:31:49 Dr. Gray introduces the concept of autonomy-supportive parenting, which goes beyond simply trusting a child to also creating conditions for independence in a world that is working against it. This means asking a child what they would like to do independently that they have not yet tried, negotiating a first step, and walking with them toward it rather than waiting for the world to cooperate. It also means examining the reflexive fears that our culture has conditioned into us about what is dangerous for children, and distinguishing genuine risk from moral panic.

Relevant Resources

Restoring Childhood — Dr. Gray's new book, available September 15, on why the youth mental health crisis predates social media and what actually needs to change for children to thrive.
Paradigm Shift Program — My signature program where the autonomy-supportive approach Dr. Gray describes is practiced as a daily skill, alongside cost-benefit decision making and the full accommodation framework.
Mentioned in this episode:
Free Live Workshop
I'm offering a free live workshop this month: "Supporting your PDA child or teen through burnout without breaking yourself in the process."
Free Live Workshop Registration

What if a school had no mandatory classes, no grades, no homework, and no age segregation, and instead gave students a genuine vote in how the school runs? That is the Sudbury Democratic model, and it offers some real benefits for PDA children and teens.
In this episode I speak with Bryer Newlin, a youth rights and disability justice advocate, self-identified PDA adult, and staff member at Clearwater School in Seattle. We talk about what it means to experience autonomy as a bodily sense, how equalizing behavior is translated in a school setting rather than punished, why clean up can be a can't rather than a won't, and what the misconception of no rules really misses about how democratic schools actually work.
Key Takeaways

Autonomy as a Bodily Sense: How Bryer Understands Their Own PDA | 00:04:47 Bryer describes PDA as having an additional sense in the body, a felt sense of how much autonomy is present in any given moment. This is not a cognitive evaluation but a somatic one, which means declarative language alone is not enough if the energy underneath still carries an agenda. A PDA nervous system can detect when someone is walking on eggshells to disguise a demand. This is why the shift the PDA lens requires has to become embodied rather than just intellectual, for parents and educators alike.

What the Sudbury Democratic Model Is and Why It May Fit PDA Nervous Systems | 00:08:32 Clearwater School has no mandatory classes, no grades, no tests, no homework, and no age segregation. Students and staff together vote on school rules, room usage, and daily structures in what is called school meeting. What makes this a natural fit for many PDA children and teens is that intrinsic motivation drives all engagement, children have genuine say in decisions that affect them, and no adult is placed above the child as the authority on what and when to learn. Bryer is also honest about what remains hard: the democratic structure still generates demands, conflict between students requires navigation, and two PDA students in the same space can struggle significantly before finding their way to each other.

Translating Equalizing Behavior Instead of Reacting to It | 00:12:17 When a student held water over a school computer and threatened to pour it on, Bryer heard something different: I am scared you are going to kick me out of school, so I am going to try to get kicked out first to have more control. Responding to what was actually being communicated changed the entire interaction. Bryer also names the everyday version of this that happens in families: when a child asking for something is told to say please first, they are placed in a doubly vulnerable position, already below as the asker and now required to go further below before the need is met. For a PDA nervous system, that is two layers of activation at once.

Can't Versus Won't and Why Allowing a Messy Child May Produce a Cleaner Adult | 00:30:40 When Bryer allows a PDA student to opt out of cleanup, the fear is always the same: you are creating an entitled adult. What Bryer has observed is the opposite. Forcing cleanup when the nervous system cannot access it produces trauma around the task and long-term avoidance. Releasing the expectation allows the child to develop their own relationship to it over time. Bryer names this as the heart of the can't versus won't distinction: believing a child when they say they cannot, even when physical capacity appears to be present, because the invisible walls of cumulative demand load may mean this particular thing cannot be scaled right now.

What Parents and Teachers Can Take Into Any Setting | 00:42:32 Bryer's message to parents navigating school refusal and fear of learning loss is direct: the time spent genuinely understanding and valuing a child's interests is a far stronger predictor of long-term success than attendance records. For teachers within public school constraints, Bryer names two starting points: learn what equalizing behavior is and what it is actually communicating, and give accommodations even when you suspect the child could physically comply, because cumulative demand load may mean they simply cannot right now. When a PDA child asks for an accommodation, Bryer reminds us, they are already doing something extremely vulnerable: willingly placing themselves below. That deserves to be met.

Relevant Resources

Clearwater School — The Seattle-area Sudbury Democratic School where Bryer works, offering a student-directed, democratic learning environment for families in Washington state and available for consultation for out-of-state families as well.
Hollow Earth Radio — Bryer's radio show airs every second Sunday at 2PM on KHUH FM, featuring themed music sets and available to stream online.
Queer COVID Cautious Creatives on Instagram — The community arts organization Bryer runs for queer and disabled people in the Pacific Northwest, reachable on Instagram at @queercovidcautiouscreatives
Paradigm Shift Program — My signature program where the embodied shift from demand-based to autonomy-based interaction is practiced as a skill over twelve weeks, alongside the full accommodation framework and live coaching
Mentioned in this episode:
Free Live Workshop
I'm offering a free live workshop this month: "Supporting your PDA child or teen through burnout without breaking yourself in the process."
Free Live Workshop Registration

This episode is a throwback to one of the most popular episodes in the history of this podcast, originally recorded as a live presentation I gave in 2022 at the Miami Sudbury Democratic School. I am releasing it again during September, a month I am dedicating to school and education content, because I keep hearing from teachers, therapists, and parents who are still looking for language to explain what they are seeing in the classroom.
In this presentation I walk through the nervous system mechanism underlying PDA, the two most common paths PDA children take through school systems, and five observable characteristics that often appear regardless of whether a child is more externalized or internalized, age, or a formal diagnosis.
Key Takeaways

Why Seventy Percent of PDA Children Cannot Access Any School: Two Paths | 00:03:49 The first path is a child who appears completely fine at school, does not qualify for an IEP or a 504, and whose teachers and administrators do not see what the parents are describing at home. But things are escalating at home, basic needs are being impacted, and the parents eventually pull the child from school feeling like no one believes them. The second path is a child whose high social communication skills lead professionals to call them high functioning, and when the behavioral expression of the disability appears, they are labeled as a defiant behavioral problem rather than a child with a nervous system disability. Both paths end in the same place: outside the school system.

The First Observable Characteristic: Equalizing Behavior | 00:13:26 Equalizing is what the body does when the nervous system has perceived a loss of autonomy and is trying to get back to a place of safety and equality. In a classroom it can look like reflexively touching something after being told not to, changing the rules of an activity, starting a worksheet in the middle, writing words backwards, walking away, putting a head down, or reducing meaningful speech. In a home it can look like targeting a sibling, knocking things over, or saying stop talking every time a parent speaks. What matters most is the adult response in that moment.

The Second and Third Characteristics: Masking and Undivided Attention | 00:18:08 Masking in PDA takes two forms: the learned social imitation most people understand, and what I call autonomic nervous system masking, where a child is experiencing full fight, flight or freeze internally while appearing calm externally. This is the primary reason PDA goes unrecognized and why parents are disbelieved: the child can look completely typical everywhere except at home, where they feel safe enough for the threat response to surface. The third characteristic is the need for a safe nervous system, meaning these children often cannot engage independently without a co-regulator nearby. My son needed us to draw what was in his brain for months, sitting next to him in an undivided way, before he could return to drawing himself.

The Fourth Characteristic: The Cumulative Nature of Nervous System Activation | 00:25:17 The ABC framework of antecedent, behavior, consequence does not apply to PDA because the actual causal moment is not the thing that happened right before the meltdown. It is the ten things that happened across the past day, week, or month, each of which registered a small loss of autonomy, building until a small trigger tips the child over. In my son's Montessori school, when a hard moment happens, we never ask what happened right before. We ask what has been accumulating.

Why Viewing PDA as a Nervous System Disability Changes Everything About Accommodation | 00:00:00 The most important shift I can offer any teacher, therapist, or parent is to put on the nervous system and autonomy lens first, before the sensory lens, before the social communication lens, and before the behavioral lens. When we understand that a child moving toward the campfire after being told to stay back, or refusing to eat the more we encourage them, is the survival drive for autonomy overriding other survival instincts, the accommodation becomes clear: reduce the perception of lost autonomy, provide nervous system safety, and trust that the behavior is not defiance but a subconscious nervous system response to perceived threat.

Relevant Resources

Paradigm Shift Program — My signature program where the full accommodation framework, including the autonomy and nervous system safety tools introduced in this presentation, are practiced live across twelve weeks of coaching.
Mentioned in this episode:
Free Live Workshop
I'm offering a free live workshop this month: "Supporting your PDA child or teen through burnout without breaking yourself in the process."
Free Live Workshop Registration

What does it look like when a school actually meets a PDA child where they are, without behavior charts, compliance goals, or pressure to perform? In this episode I speak with three remarkable people: Melissa Petro, a cultural journalist and mother of an eight-year-old PDA son who fought for years to secure him a free and appropriate education; Chela Crane, Executive Director of Otto Specht School in New York, where Melissa's son Oscar is now thriving; and Suchi Swift, a Waldorf teacher at Otto Specht who works directly with Oscar.
Together we cover Oscar's journey from expulsion at preschool and eight months of homeschooling through burnout, to the slow, non-linear process of rebuilding trust and regulation at a school that does not measure success through compliance. We also talk about what public school teachers can take from this model, what one family went through in fighting for private school placement, and what it actually looks like when a PDA child gets back into their thinking brain consistently and begins to lead their own learning.

Key Takeaways

Expelled at Preschool, Eight Months of Homeschool, and What Burnout Looked Like | 00:03:45 Melissa's son Oscar was expelled from preschool after behavior charts, smiley face stickers, and compliance-based interventions produced aggression and shutdown rather than regulation. By the time he left school, his toileting had regressed, he had stopped eating, he had become aggressive with his sister, and he was nonverbal in the moments he most needed to communicate. Eight months of homeschooling followed, during which Melissa was simultaneously fighting the school district and caregiving for her son as his sole accommodation. One thing I want parents to hear in this story is what I see consistently across the families I work with: the behaviors that get a child expelled are the nervous system in survival mode, not the child.

The Legal Fight for FAPE and Why It Is So Opaque | 00:08:51 To secure reimbursement for a private placement, a family must prove in court that the district failed to design an appropriate IEP, failed to find a public program that meets it, and then find a private program that does. Parents who succeed are often compelled to sign NDAs, which keeps the process invisible to other families who need it most. Melissa describes being accused of educational neglect for not following a behavioral prescription she knew in her gut did not fit her son. The fight for a free and appropriate public education, which every child is legally entitled to in the United States, is one of the most traumatizing experiences I hear about from families navigating this system.

What the Otto Specht School Does Differently: Rhythm, Observation, and No Compliance Goal | 00:18:23 Suchi describes shifting her morning attendance routine from a desk task to a chalkboard drawing, which Oscar began arriving early to complete, drawing detailed tiger lilies to mark his presence. Chela names the single biggest difference in their model: success is never measured as compliance. Regulation and engagement come first, always, and academic skill development can only follow once those foundations are present. There are no behavior charts, no incentive systems, and no pressure on teachers to cover content regardless of where a child's nervous system is on a given day.

How Oscar Got There: Trust, Time, and Self-Directed Exposure | 00:39:57 For the first year and a half, Melissa was not sure it was working. Oscar still had school refusal every day. The school allowed him to bring his snake and his kitten as transitional objects. But over time he want from leaving the room during music class to sitting on the side and drawing, then joining in, and then performing a solo in the school play. He could not ride a bike, and Melissa dropped the idea entirely at home, but then when he was ready Suchi taught him at school. He is now a musical theater kid who loves bike riding! What I see in that arc is what I try to help parents understand: self-directed, intrinsically motivated exposure at the pace the nervous system is ready for produces genuine skill and genuine joy. It cannot be rushed.

What Teachers and Administrators Can Take From This, Even in Public Schools | 00:52:41 Suchi offers two practical starting points for any teacher: make attendance creative rather than procedural, and get to know every child's pet by name. Chela names the reframe that changes everything in any setting: behavior is information, not defiance. When we stop trying to change the behavior and start asking what the behavior is telling us, the nervous system underneath becomes visible and workable. Both teachers acknowledge that public school constraints are real and not the fault of individual teachers. But even within those constraints, one small shift toward curiosity and away from compliance as the primary metric can change the experience of a PDA child in that classroom.

Relevant Resources

Otto Specht School Website — The school featured in this episode, offering a Waldorf-based, neuro-affirming educational program for children who learn differently in New York. Families and educators are welcome to reach out directly.
Otto Specht School on Instagram — Follow Otto Specht School for ongoing content about their educational model, student life, and approach to neurodivergent learners.
Melissa Petro — Melissa's website, where she writes about PDA advocacy, educational exclusion, and the emotional toll of parenting a neurodivergent child. She is also reachable on Instagram and Facebook at Melissa Petro.
Understanding PDA — Free class where I teach the nervous system disability framework and the felt safety and window of tolerance concepts that underlie the Otto Specht model described in this episode.
Paradigm Shift Program — My signature program where the accommodation framework, cost-benefit decision making, and advocacy tools Melissa describes using are taught across twelve weeks of live coaching.
Mentioned in this episode:
Free Live Workshop
I'm offering a free live workshop this month: "Supporting your PDA child or teen through burnout without breaking yourself in the process."
Free Live Workshop Registration